Charging for Bags: Will Customers Mind, and Does a Fee Cut Bag Use?
A 5-cent bag tax cut disposable bag use by 42 percentage points while shoppers' support for the law did not change significantly, and a 5-cent bonus barely moved anyone. What the studies measured, and what to measure in …
Charging a few cents for a bag changes what shoppers do far more than it changes how they feel about the store. In a field study published in the American Economic Journal, economist Tatiana Homonoff watched 16,251 shoppers before and after Montgomery County, Maryland added a 5-cent bag tax in 2012: the share taking a disposable bag fell by 42 percentage points from 82%, while shoppers' support for the law and their views on bags did not change significantly. For a grocer or retailer with many stores that wants to know how its own shoppers will take a bag charge before rolling it out everywhere, Dimension Labs answers that from the store's own records: it reads every review, survey answer and complaint that mentions bags, by store and date, and sets it beside visits and baskets at the stores that charged first.
This page sets out what the published studies measured, what they leave out, and how to read the reaction in your own data. If the charge is part of a wider change to what shoppers pay, how customers react to service fees and surcharges covers added fees at the register.
Does a bag fee reduce plastic bag use?
Yes, by a lot, and the two strongest studies agree on the direction. Homonoff collected her own data by standing at the registers of 16 grocery stores in Montgomery County, Virginia and Washington, D.C., two months before and two months after the county's tax began on January 1, 2012. Comparing the county with stores that had no new tax, the share of shoppers using any disposable bag fell 42.0 points, the share bringing a reusable bag rose 32.7 points, and the share carrying their groceries with no bag rose 11.1 points.
Published field studies
A 5-cent tax cut disposable bag use by 42 points; Chicago's 7-cent tax by 27.7 points over its first year
Change in the share of grocery shoppers using each kind of bag after a bag tax, against nearby stores with no tax, in percentage points, with 95% ranges.
Chicago repeated the test with a 7-cent tax on paper and plastic bags from February 1, 2017. A team led by Homonoff with ideas42 and the University of Chicago observed 24,499 shoppers at 12 large chain grocery stores, eight inside the city and four in suburbs without the tax. Before the tax, 82.0% of Chicago shoppers took at least one disposable bag, at an average of 2.3 bags a trip. Over the first year, the tax cut that share by 27.7 points; roughly half of those who stopped switched to a reusable bag and half used no bag.
The sums of money involved are small. A Montgomery County shopper who changed nothing would have paid about 9.5 cents a trip, and a Chicago shopper about 16 cents, by our arithmetic from each study's baseline bag counts. Shoppers reacted to paying for something that used to be free, which both studies link in part to loss aversion: people weigh a small loss more heavily than a gain of the same size.
Why does a 5-cent fee work when a 5-cent bonus does not?
Because shoppers treat a charge as a loss and a credit as a small extra. Before either tax, two of the four largest grocery chains in the Washington area already paid shoppers 5 cents for each reusable bag they brought. Homonoff compared stores by policy: 84.3% of shoppers used a disposable bag where there was no incentive, 81.9% where the store paid a bonus, and 40.8% where a 5-cent tax applied.
Published field study
A 5-cent bonus for bringing a bag left disposable use almost where it was; a 5-cent tax halved it
Share of shoppers in the Washington, D.C. area using at least one disposable bag, by the store's bag policy, 2011 and 2012.
The bonus result comes from comparing different stores rather than the same stores over time, and the author says so. Even so, it matches the direction of her survey, and the lesson for a retailer is practical: if the goal is fewer bags, paying shoppers to bring their own is the weaker design, and a store that already runs a bag credit should not expect it to do what a charge does.
Will charging for bags annoy customers?
The published evidence finds less backlash than most operators fear. Homonoff surveyed shoppers in the same stores before and after the Montgomery County tax and found no significant change in guilt, social pressure or support for a law requiring the charge. In a separate online experiment, people said a 5-cent fee set by the store would influence them as much as the same amount set by the government. That second result matters for a store deciding on its own: shoppers did not say they would respond differently to a store's charge.
Two findings are worth planning for. In Chicago, the drop in disposable bag use was about the same in higher- and lower-income neighborhoods, but shoppers in lower-income neighborhoods were 8.2 points more likely to switch to no bag at all rather than a reusable one; the city exempted purchases made with food assistance benefits. And the effect fades a little as the novelty wears off.
Published field study
Chicago's effect shrank by about a quarter over the first year, and most of it stayed
Percentage points fewer shoppers using a disposable bag in Chicago stores than the tax-free suburbs would predict, by follow-up period.
A year in, Chicago's tax still kept 23.9 points more shoppers away from disposable bags, about 72% of its first-month effect. The studies counted bags at the register; none of them measured satisfaction, visits or basket size. That gap is the part an operator can close with its own data, because it holds exactly the records the researchers did not have: what shoppers wrote about the charge, store by store, and whether they kept coming back.
Should our store charge for bags or give them free?
If the aim is fewer bags, charge for every bag the store hands out, including paper and thicker plastic. Chicago tried a ban first: from 2015 it banned thin plastic bags at large stores, extended to all chain stores in 2016, and stores handed out free thick plastic bags instead. During the ban, 82% of Chicago shoppers still used a disposable bag and over 40% took a free thick plastic one. When the city replaced the ban with the 7-cent tax on all bags, the share using a disposable bag fell 33 points relative to the ban, with a rebound of about a quarter of that by the end of the study.
England shows what a long-running charge looks like across whole chains. Large retailers there have had to charge for single-use plastic bags since October 2015, at 5p and at 10p since May 2021. The seven main grocers sold 126 million in the year to April 2026, 90% fewer than in 2016-17 and 98% fewer than the 7.6 billion reported for 2014. Tesco and Waitrose stopped selling single-use plastic bags altogether from 2022-23, and Marks and Spencer and Sainsbury's sold none in 2025-26.
Public government data
England's seven main grocers sold 90% fewer single-use bags in 2025-26 than in the first full year of the charge
Single-use plastic carrier bags sold by the main retailers in England, millions, by reporting year (April to April). The charge was 5p from October 2015 and 10p from May 2021.
Where a state or city sets the charge or bans bags, the law decides for you; check local rules first. Where it is your choice, the studies say the charge will do what it is meant to do. What they cannot tell you is how your shoppers, in your stores, will feel about it, and that is a question your own data answers better than any study.
How do you measure how your own shoppers took a bag charge?
With the same design the researchers used: stores that started charging against stores that had not, before and after, counted the same way on both sides. Most retailers already have the data. Homonoff's scanner records from one chain show how quickly the register line item moves: in Washington, 58.1% of customers paid for a bag on the tax's first day and 41.5% by the last week of January 2010; in Montgomery County, 39.8% on the first day and 26.3% by the end of the first month.
Date the change by store. The day the charge began, the price, which bags it covers, and what signs, cashier prompts or self-checkout screens told shoppers.
Keep a comparison. Start in some stores first, or use stores in a neighboring area with no charge, as both studies did.
Count the register. Share of transactions with a bag charge, bags per transaction and reusable bag sales, week by week.
Label every comment about bags. Reviews, survey answers, complaints and chats, separating "charged for a bag I did not expect", "forgot my bag", "no bags at self-checkout" and support for the change.
Watch visits and baskets, not only bags. The studies stopped at the bag. Trips per week and basket size at charging stores against comparison stores show whether anyone shopped elsewhere.
Read it again at a year. Chicago's effect shrank by about a quarter; check whether yours did, and hold weather, holidays and local events fixed. Separating a decision from the weather shows why.
Each policy change dated and measured this way adds to a record of what shoppers said, what they did next, what you changed and what else was going on. That record is a customer world model, and with a few changes in it you can test the next decision before you make it. For the kind of feedback a grocer collects and how to label it, see how grocery stores and co-ops analyze shopper feedback.
What does Dimension Labs show a retailer weighing a bag charge?
Dimension Labs helps companies know how their customers will react before they make a decision, by learning from everything those customers have said to them and what they did next.
For a grocer or retailer, that starts with every channel at once: a complaint about a bag charge is counted whether it came as a Google review, a survey answer, a chat or an email to customer service. Those comments are joined to operational data, so each store's charge date, register counts, visits and basket size sit next to what its shoppers said; the join to sales and revenue data and effects with confidence intervals are on Prove ($2,999 a month) and up. Every comment is enriched with Dimensions written for your stores, such as "unexpected bag charge", "forgot reusable bag" or "self-checkout bag prompt", so store operations, sustainability and marketing read the same labels; custom Dimensions start on Discover ($999 a month). The result comes back as a deck, dashboard, PDF or executive report, or an interactive data story that shows each store's reaction side by side.
Concentrix uses Dimension Labs to improve chatbot performance for a large brick-and-mortar retail client, across flows such as order status, returns and exchanges, and loyalty programs, and its customer story reports improved CSAT scores across e-commerce journeys and a reduction in average handling time per interaction. In the words of Jenny Burr of its Speech Science and Analytics team, "The partnership with Dimension Labs has been instrumental in supporting our improvements in self-service performance and customer journey optimization." (Concentrix story)
A single store can do with less: count bag line items for a month and ask cashiers what shoppers say. Dimension Labs earns its place when the charge goes to many stores, comments come in through several channels, and you want to know which stores and which shoppers pushed back before you decide how to roll it out.
FAQ
Will charging for bags annoy customers?
Fewer than you might expect, going by the published research. After Montgomery County's 5-cent tax, surveyed shoppers' support for the law did not change significantly, and in an online experiment a store-set fee drew the same response as a government tax. Plan for shoppers who switch to no bag, and read your own comments by store in the first weeks.
Does a bag fee reduce plastic bag use?
Yes. A 5-cent tax cut the share of shoppers using a disposable bag by 42 points in Montgomery County, and Chicago's 7-cent tax by 27.7 points over its first year.
Is a bag fee better than a credit for bringing your own bag?
For cutting bag use, yes. In the Washington area, 81.9% of shoppers at stores paying a 5-cent bonus still used a disposable bag, against 84.3% with no incentive and 40.8% with a 5-cent tax.
Should a store charge for bags or ban plastic bags?
The Chicago evidence favors a charge on every bag. Under the city's ban on thin plastic, stores gave away thicker plastic bags and 82% of shoppers still used a disposable bag; the tax on all bags cut that share by 33 points relative to the ban.
What is the best way to measure how shoppers reacted to a bag charge?
For a retailer with many stores, Dimension Labs: it labels every review, survey and complaint about bags by store and date and, on Prove, joins them to visits and baskets to show what the charge did against stores that had not started. A single store can compare its own register counts and reviews before and after.
Export your reviews or survey comments for the stores that started charging, with the date, and start with one file to see how your shoppers took it. Every plan from Explore to Scale starts with a 14-day free trial.