Resort-Fee Searches Doubled After the FTC Rule. They Doubled in California Too.
Resort-fee searches doubled after the FTC fee rule took effect in May 2025. They doubled in California too, where all-in prices were a year old. Why guest reaction to a fee lives in each hotel's own record.
If you sell hotel rooms, here is the easy version of the story. The FTC's fee rule made hotels show the total price up front from May 12, 2025, and U.S. searches for resort fees more than doubled in the second half of 2025, a rise of 116.4% on the same weeks a year earlier. It reads like proof that guests noticed.
Then look at California, where hotels had already been required to show all-in prices since July 1, 2024, so the booking screen there changed much less when the rule arrived. Resort-fee searches rose 109.3% in California too, and against California the states the rule newly covered landed anywhere from 27.8 points lower to 2.5 points higher. My read is that the rule changed where hotels show resort fees, and in public data it left no mark that can be told apart from the national attention around it. What changed for guests happened on booking screens and at check-in, and that is where a hotel's own reviews, chats and bookings can measure it.
What follows is a decision autopsy of the rule. We read the rule, the state law and every study behind it at the source, then compared searches in three states the rule newly covered with California, which had made the same change ten months earlier. Public data stops at attention. A hotel group, vacation-rental operator or ticket seller weighing its next fee or price-display change holds the rest: the reviews, chats and calls that name the fee, by property and date, and the bookings that followed. That record is what we built Dimension Labs to read: it joins the record to bookings and rates and measures the change against properties or channels that did not change.
What does the FTC fee rule require hotels to show?
The Commission voted 4 to 1 on December 17, 2024 to finalize the Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees, with Commissioner Andrew Ferguson dissenting, after a proposed rule in October 2023 drew more than 60,000 comments. It was published in the Federal Register on January 10, 2025 and took effect on May 12, 2025. It covers two industries only: live-event tickets, and short-term lodging, which the rule defines as temporary sleeping accommodations at a hotel, motel, inn, short-term rental, vacation rental or other place of lodging.
The rule does not ban resort fees. It requires the total price, including every mandatory fee, to be shown more prominently than any other price, and lets a business leave out only government charges, shipping and optional extras. The FTC's own example: a resort that charges $199 a night plus a mandatory $39 daily resort fee must include the fee in the total price. Hotels may still itemize the fee, as long as the itemized line does not overshadow the total.
Why is California the right comparison for the FTC rule?
The rule is close to a natural experiment, for three reasons. It took effect on one date, nationwide. The same hotel companies sell through the same websites in every state. And one large state had already moved: California's honest pricing law, SB 478, has required listed prices to include all mandatory fees since July 1, 2024, for hotels, short-term rentals and event tickets among others. The Federal Register notes that national lodging and ticketing firms had already built the capability to comply in California, even if they were then deploying it fully only there. So California is the comparison group: on May 12, 2025, what guests saw at booking changed in most states and changed much less in California.
We compared California with Texas, Florida and Nevada, three large lodging states that appear in none of the Federal Register's lists of states with their own fee laws and that have enough resort-fee searches to measure week by week. Thirteen other states we checked had too many weeks with no recorded searches. We compare the weeks starting July 1 to December 31 of each year, because California's law began on July 1, 2024: the second half of 2024 is the one stretch when California showed all-in prices and the other three did not. Comparing the same weeks each year also holds the travel season still, the same way our autopsy of California's $20 fast-food wage compared California with states where nothing changed.
Dated decisions
Fee display moved in California first and nationwide ten months later
The rule and the events around it, with dates from the regulators' own pages.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| Jan 2017 | FTC economists publish an analysis of hotel resort fees |
| Oct 2023 | FTC proposes the fee rule |
| Jul 1, 2024 | California SB 478 takes effect: listed prices must include mandatory fees |
| Dec 17, 2024 | FTC finalizes the rule for live-event tickets and short-term lodging, 4 to 1 |
| May 12, 2025 | The rule takes effect nationwide |
| Apr 9, 2026 | StubHub agrees to refund $10 million in fees in an FTC case citing the rule |
| Jul 2, 2026 | Hopper agrees to pay $35 million to settle FTC allegations, including violations of the rule on lodging bookings since May 12, 2025 |
What did the published research find about resort fees and hidden fees?
The case for the rule rests on a small body of evidence, and most of it is about how people shop rather than what they write afterwards. Mary Sullivan of the FTC's Bureau of Economics concluded in January 2017 that separating mandatory resort fees from the room rate without first showing the total price is likely to harm consumers, by raising the cost of searching and comparing; she reported that seven percent of U.S. hotels charged resort fees and that consumers paid about $2 billion in them in 2015, figures she drew from a Reuters report.
The strongest causal evidence comes from tickets, the rule's other industry. In a field experiment on StubHub, Blake, Moshary, Sweeney and Tadelis found that showing fees up front reduced both how many tickets people bought and the quality of the seats they chose, and that visitors who saw fees only at checkout spent almost 21% more. The FTC relied on the study in its rule. A 2025 study of the FlyerTalk travel forum by Jankuhn, Kuang and Sim adds the guest's view: resort fees often cause dissatisfaction when their disclosure is opaque, and may signal quality when hotels disclose them early and tie them to high-value amenities.
The industry's own count is smaller than the 2017 figure. The American Hotel & Lodging Association said on the day the rule was finalized that only 6% of hotels nationwide charge a mandatory resort, destination or amenity fee, averaging $26 a night, and that it favored one national standard for showing fees. The FTC used the same 6% to estimate that 2,953 of 49,216 U.S. lodging firms charge such fees, and put the rule's benefit for lodging at 27.2 million to 39.6 million hours of search time saved a year, worth $702.1 million to $1.02 billion. Those are estimates of time saved, made before the rule took effect; none of the studies measures how guests reacted afterwards.
Published research, read at the source
The evidence is about how people shop; the reaction after the rule is unmeasured
What each source found, from what data, and who supported or supplied it where the source says so.
| Source | What it found | Data, support |
|---|---|---|
| Sullivan, FTC 2017 | Separate resort fees without a total price likely harm consumers by raising search costs; 7% of hotels charged them (from Reuters) | Literature review; FTC staff paper |
| Blake et al. 2021 | Showing fees up front cut ticket purchases and the quality of seats chosen; visitors who saw fees late spent almost 21% more | Field experiment on StubHub; StubHub shared the data |
| Jankuhn et al. 2025 | Opaque disclosure drives dissatisfaction; disclosed early and tied to amenities, fees may signal quality | Posts on the FlyerTalk forum |
| AHLA 2024 | 6% of hotels charge a mandatory fee, averaging $26 a night; backs one national standard | Industry association statement |
| FTC rule 2025 | 27.2 million to 39.6 million hours of lodging search time saved a year, $702.1 million to $1.02 billion | Regulatory estimate made before the rule took effect |
Read together, the research explains why the rule was written. None of it says what guests did afterwards, and that is the question an operator actually has. The rest of this piece takes it to public data, and shows where a company's own record has to take over.
What did travelers search for after the rule took effect?
Search is the one public record of customer attention that covers every state, every week, before and after the date. Nationally, the rule's two covered fee terms rose faster than fees it does not touch. Searches for resort fees rose 116.4% and for cleaning fees, the vacation-rental charge, 119.6%, from the second half of 2024 to the second half of 2025. Searches for ATM fees, convenience fees and airline baggage fees rose 51.5% to 57.8% over the same weeks, and a year earlier every one of the five had moved by less than 13%.
Dimension Labs analysis, Google Trends
Searches for every kind of fee rose after mid-2025, the two the rule covers fastest
Change in U.S. search interest, weeks starting July 1 to December 31, 2024 against the same weeks of 2025, in percent. One request, so all five terms share a scale.
A gap like that ends up in a board deck as proof the rule changed customer behavior. California is why I would keep it out. The comparison shows no sign that the rise came from the booking screen. In the same weeks, resort-fee searches rose 109.3% in California, where all-in prices were a year old, 106.2% in Florida, 173.7% in Texas and 16.3% in Nevada, where interest was already the highest of the four. Averaged, the three states the rule newly covered landed 10.5 points lower than California, with a 90% range from 27.8 points lower to 2.5 points higher. General searches for hotels moved together too: 1.5 points lower (range 2.9 points lower to 0.7 points higher).
Dimension Labs analysis, Google Trends
Where the rule changed the booking screen, resort-fee searches showed no detectable difference from California
Change in search interest in states where the price display was new, minus the change where it was not, in percentage points, with 90% ranges. Weeks starting July 1 to December 31 each year.
Dashed line: no difference
Could the rise in searches be a reaction to the new booking screens?
We ran four checks that would have exposed a real effect if there were one. First, a year when nothing changed anywhere: the same comparison from 2022 to 2023 gives 13.7 points lower (range 21.0 to 8.4 points lower), a larger gap than the one after the rule, and one whose range excludes zero. State-to-state noise in this term is as large as any effect the rule could have had, and the 90% ranges understate it. Second, California's own law, run the other way: from 2023 to 2024, when California's display changed and the others' did not, California moved 6.6 points lower than the three (range 18.5 points lower to 0.7 points higher). Neither display change, in either direction, separated from the noise.
Third, a fee the rule does not touch: ATM-fee searches in Texas and Florida moved 2.0 points higher than California's (range 13.7 points lower to 12.2 points higher), so the doubling hit fees with no rule at all. Fourth, the answer depends on which state is left out: without Texas the gap is 48.0 points lower, and without Nevada it is 30.7 points higher. With one state able to flip the sign, the three-state comparison cannot support an effect in either direction. A second pull with the date range shifted by a week returned identical weekly values, which rules out a one-off error in a single request, though not the sampling behind the series.
One more view gives the same answer. Measured in one request so both share a scale, California's resort-fee searches ran at 1.81 times the U.S. rate in the second half of 2023, 1.69 times in 2024 and 1.61 times in 2025. If the rule had cut searches where it was new, California's ratio would have risen in 2025; it fell 4.9%, a smaller move than the 9.4% rise from 2022 to 2023, when no display changed. Every fee term we checked, covered or not, also spiked together in July 2025 and again from November 2025 to June 2026. Movements that hit unrelated fees at the same moment point to attention, or to changes in the search data itself, rather than to one industry's price display.
Without these checks, this piece would have told the clean story the national chart tells: the rule took effect and searches for the fees it covers doubled. The comparison group, the year with no rule and the fee with no rule each show the data cannot support that story. A company running the same checks on its own bookings and reviews, across dozens of properties, gets a comparison strong enough to answer it.
Did hotel prices jump when fees moved into the headline price?
Not in the government's price data. The Consumer Price Index for hotels and motels is collected mostly from booking websites, includes taxes, and counts resort or destination fees paid at check-in when they are clearly described. If clearer fees had raised what guests paid, the index would be the place to see it. From May to September 2025, hotel and motel prices averaged 3.0% lower than a year earlier, after averaging 1.8% lower over the same months of 2024, while prices overall rose about 2.7%.
Public data, Bureau of Labor Statistics
Hotel prices were lower than a year earlier in the months after the rule, as they were the summer before
Twelve-month change in the Consumer Price Index, averaged over May to September of each year, in percent.
The index cannot say why, and I would not guess. Hotels may have folded fees into room rates, dropped them, or kept them and shown them earlier, and each leaves a different trace in what guests pay and write. A hotel group knows which it did, property by property, which is why the same question is answerable from its own rate and fee records.
What can public data not show, and what answers it?
Search shows attention, not bookings. Google Trends is drawn from a sample of searches, each value is a term's share of all searches in that place and week, scaled from 0 to 100 and rounded to a whole number, and terms with low volume appear as zero. Values are relative, so each state's series is compared only with itself, as a percent change; the 90% ranges come from redrawing the weeks in 4-week blocks 4,000 times and keeping the middle 90% of results. Low volume is why only four states could be measured, and why the Nevada and Texas series alone can swing the answer. A hotel group has the record that closes each gap:
- Where the guest met the fee. Public search cannot tell a booking-screen surprise from a news story. Reviews, chats and front-desk complaints that mention a fee are dated and tied to a property and a booking channel.
- Whether it cost bookings. Search interest is not a booking. A company's search-to-book funnel and reservation records show whether guests left at the price page after the display changed.
- What the hotel did. The price index cannot tell folded, dropped and itemized fees apart. The company's own rate and fee history can, property by property.
- A real comparison group. Three states are a thin control. A chain with properties that changed on different dates, or channels that showed fees differently, has dozens of comparisons inside its own data.
We also looked for what guests wrote. Google reviews have no public bulk export, and we did not use a paid scraper. Our own public-review data covers Orlando only: in public Google reviews of 45 Orlando hotels, mentions of a resort or destination fee fell from 24.4 to 13.6 per 1,000 rated reviews from early 2025 to the same dates of 2026, and reviews calling the fee hidden fell from 7 to 2, as what changed in hotel reviews after resort fees had to be shown in the price sets out. That drop has no comparison group, so it cannot be credited to the rule on its own. It does show where the signal lives: in what guests wrote about the stay, which is exactly the record a hotel group holds for every property and can compare the right way.
What should a hotel group or ticket seller do before its next fee or display change?
Most fee decisions are smaller than a federal rule: a new amenity fee at a set of resorts, a parking charge, a booking fee on one channel, a change in how a price is shown in the app. If I were making one, this is what I would do first.
- Separate the fee from the display. Raising a fee and showing it earlier are different decisions with different reactions. The research above says the timing of disclosure drives much of the complaint; measure the two apart.
- Find the version that already happened. A property that bundled its fee into the rate, a channel that showed totals before the others, California since July 2024: each is a natural experiment on your own guests. How to test a business decision before you make it sets out the steps.
- Compare with properties that did not change, in the same weeks. Travel is seasonal and fee searches move with the news. A comparison group carries both, as it did here.
- Run the checks before you trust the number. A year with no change, the comparison run the other way, an unrelated fee, and leaving one location out. The national doubling above would have been credited to the rule without them. How to backtest a decision you already made shows the scorecard approach.
- Read what guests wrote, not only what they searched. Label every review, chat and survey comment for the fee, the surprise and the price, so the first property where a change goes wrong is visible within days. Reading price perception in customer comments covers the labels.
Restaurants face the same question with service fees and card surcharges, covered in how customers react to added fees, and a deposit or card hold at booking is its own version, in do reservation deposits and no-show fees cost you bookings. Price increases themselves, read across many dated notices, are in our study of customer reactions to price increases.
Holding what guests said, what they did, what the business did and what the world did in one place is what we call a customer world model. A fee decision touches all four layers at once: the guest's comment, the booking, the rate the hotel set and a federal rule.
Where does Dimension Labs fit for a hotel or ticket seller changing how it shows prices?
Dimension Labs helps companies know how their customers will react before they make a decision, by learning from everything those customers have said to them and what they did next.
A guest who meets a surprise fee may say so in a review, a post-stay survey, a chat with the front desk or a call to reservations. Dimension Labs reads all of those channels together, so the complaint is counted wherever it was made. It connects them to the operational record a fee decision needs: bookings, rates, fee schedules, the property list and the date each property changed its display. Each conversation is enriched with Dimensions written for lodging, such as "fee not disclosed", "charged more than quoted", "resort fee worth it" or "price matched the booking", which revenue management, operations and guest relations all read the same way. The findings go out as decks, dashboards, PDF and executive reports and shareable links that leadership can open. The join to bookings and revenue, and effects with confidence intervals against comparison properties, are on the Prove plan ($2,999 a month) and up; custom Dimensions start on Discover ($999).
Travelers, which runs customer conversations across voice, chat, email, SMS and self-service, unified them in Dimension Labs and reported 600% ROI within 18 months and $3.13M in total savings. For live events, the rule's other industry, the NBA cut its insight review cycles from about 60 days to under 6 hours.
I will be direct about who does not need us. A single hotel that changed its fee display once is better served by something simpler: bookings against the same weeks last year and a careful read of its reviews. A group with many properties, several booking channels and changes made on different dates has the comparison groups this public analysis lacked, and that is the case Dimension Labs is built for.
FAQ
Does the FTC fee rule ban hotel resort fees?
No. It requires the total price, with every mandatory fee, to be the most prominent price shown, from the first price a guest sees. In the FTC's example, a $199 room with a mandatory $39 daily resort fee must be advertised with the fee included. Taxes, shipping and optional extras may be left out of the headline and disclosed before payment.
Which businesses does the FTC fee rule cover?
Sellers of live-event tickets and of short-term lodging: hotels, motels, inns, short-term rentals, vacation rentals and other places of lodging, including the websites and apps that sell them. States can add stronger rules; California's has applied to most consumer prices since July 1, 2024.
Did the FTC rule change how guests react to resort fees?
Public data cannot isolate it. Searches for resort fees doubled after the rule, but they doubled in California too, where all-in prices were already required, and the gap between newly covered states and California ranged from 27.8 points lower to 2.5 points higher. The reaction lives in what guests wrote and booked at each property, which a hotel group can compare against properties or channels that did not change.
Has the FTC enforced the fee rule?
Yes. In April 2026 StubHub agreed to refund $10 million in fees in a case citing the rule, and in July 2026 the travel app Hopper agreed to pay $35 million, to settle FTC allegations that included violating the rule on short-term lodging bookings since May 12, 2025.
What is the best way to measure how guests react to a fee or price-display change?
For a hotel group or ticket seller with reviews, surveys and bookings by property or channel, Dimension Labs: it labels every comment for the fee, the surprise and the price, joins them to bookings and rates on Prove, and reports each effect against properties that did not change, with a range. For one property, a same-weeks-last-year comparison and a careful read of reviews will do.
Bring one export of reviews or survey comments by property that spans your last fee or pricing-display change, with its date, and start with one file to see what guests noticed and where.