Skip to content
Product
PlatformPricingDimensionsIntegrationsSecurityCompare
Solutions · by use case
Customer, guest and fan experienceProduct feedback and prioritizationRevenue, churn and retentionAgenciesContact center performanceAI agent and chatbot analyticsMulti-location performanceReviews and competitive benchmarking
Solutions · by industry
Hotels and hospitalityRestaurants and food serviceFitness and leisureRetail and e-commerceSports and live entertainmentInsuranceBanking and financial servicesSoftware and SaaSAutomotiveConsumer products and CPGContact centers and BPOsPublic sector and nonprofitReal estateGaming and betting
Learn
Artifacts GalleryCustomer storiesResearchBlogThought leadershipLessons Log in Start now
Blog

Should a Restaurant Launch a Subscription Program? What the Public Tests Show

Paid restaurant subscriptions raise visits among members, but members were usually regulars already, and three of the four public programs were later reworked or ended. What the tests show and how to run your own.

A paid subscription can raise visits among the guests who buy it, but the published results flatter it, because the buyers tend to be regulars already, and none of the public results we found compares members with similar guests who did not join. Taco Bell reported that members of its $10 taco pass were three times more likely to visit in a month, and also that 16% renewed for a second month. For a chain deciding whether a subscription would add visits or mostly discount the guests who already come, Dimension Labs gives the clearest answer, because it joins what guests say about value and the program to what they bought before and after they joined.

Below: what four public programs launched with and what each chain did next, why member results overstate the lift, how a subscription differs from a free loyalty program, and how to test one in a few locations first. Nothing here comes from private data; every figure is from a chain's own release or the trade press. For the free version of the question, see whether a restaurant should start a loyalty program.

Do restaurant subscription programs increase visits or just discount regulars?

Both, and the published numbers cannot yet tell you the split. Taco Bell's three-times figure compares members with everyone else, and Restaurant Dive reported that the pass "resulted in 20% new rewards members". Pret reported that sales per Club Pret transaction were close to 30% higher than those without a subscription. Both are comparisons between people who chose to join and people who did not.

Who chooses to join matters. In PYMNTS Intelligence's "Digital Divide: Restaurant Subscribers and Loyalty Programs" study, made with Paytronix and based on a survey of more than 2,000 US adults, 78% of restaurant subscribers called themselves very or extremely loyal to their preferred quick-service brand, against 41% of people with no interest in subscribing. If the guests who sign up were already visiting often, some of their visits would have happened anyway, and the subscription turned them into discounted visits. Pret put a number on the other side of the ledger: in 2022 its subscribers saved £50 a month on average.

Survey data

Restaurant subscribers are far more loyal than people with no interest in subscribing

Share who say they are very or extremely loyal to their preferred quick-service restaurant, by interest in subscriptions.

Restaurant subscribers
78%
Interested in a subscription
73%
Not interested
41%
0255075
Source: PYMNTS Intelligence, "Digital Divide: Restaurant Subscribers and Loyalty Programs" (February/March 2022, with Paytronix), survey of more than 2,000 US adults; all three shares as reported by PYMNTS, Nov. 21, 2023. Read November 15, 2026.

There is real evidence of lift as well. Taco Bell's chief digital officer told PYMNTS in 2023 that the company sees customers "not only increasing their behavior, but even holding some of their behavior after they use the passes," and that pass holders combine their free item with other things on the menu. The useful question for your chain is how much of each, among which guests, and that is something you can measure on your own transactions rather than infer from someone else's press release.

Should our restaurant offer a monthly subscription?

Start with what happened to the programs that went first. Three of the four public programs below were later repriced, cut back, folded into a new program or discontinued, and the fourth, Taco Bell's pass, was being offered as limited-time drops by 2023.

Public record

Four paid restaurant programs, and what each chain did next

Launch terms and later developments, as reported by the chains or the trade press.

ProgramLaunch termsReported resultsWhat happened later
Taco Bell Taco Lover's PassSept. 2021 test at 17 Tucson units, $5 to $10 for a taco a day for 30 days; national Jan. 2022 at $10Members 3x more likely to visit per month; 16% renewed for a second monthOffered as limited-time pass drops by 2023; model extended to Nacho Fries
Club Pret2020, up to five barista drinks a day for a monthly fee; 10% off food added April 2023Redemptions 34.7M (2021) to 57.9M (2022); sales per subscriber transaction close to 30% higherFood discount axed in a 2024 overhaul; a planned rise from £5 to £10 a month reversed in 2025
Sweetgreen Sweetpass+Jan. 2022 pilot, $10 for $3 off daily; national April 2023; $100 annual tier Feb. 2024Enrollment up 25% in the second half of 2023Members told in Feb. 2025 they would move to a new SG Rewards program
Burger King coffee subscriptionMonthly coffee planNot publishedDiscontinued, per Restaurant Dive (2022)
Sources: Restaurant Business, Sept. 13, 2021; Restaurant Dive, Feb. 23, 2022; PYMNTS, Nov. 21, 2023; Pret, July 18, 2023; The Caterer, Feb. 11, 2025; Mintel, May 16, 2023; Restaurant Dive, Feb. 2, 2024; Restaurant Business, Feb. 18, 2025. All read November 15, 2026.

Taco Bell tested its pass for a limited time at 17 Tucson restaurants in September 2021, at between $5 and $10 depending on location, and the test ran to November 24. It went national in January 2022 at $10 for one of seven tacos a day for 30 days. At the $1.49 listed for a Crunchy Taco at one Tucson store, a guest who redeemed every day got $44.70 of tacos for $10, about 22% of face value. By 2023 the company was running passes as limited-time drops and had extended the idea to Nacho Fries.

Club Pret started in 2020 as a coffee subscription of up to five barista drinks a day, and in April 2023 added 10% off food. Redemptions rose from 34.7 million in 2021 to 57.9 million in 2022. In 2024 Pret overhauled the scheme after admitting it had seemed "too good to be true" and dropped a 20% food discount its UK and Ireland managing director said the chain had "never really got comfortable with"; in February 2025 it reversed a plan to double the price from £5 to £10 a month.

Company data

Club Pret redemptions rose by two thirds in a year

Club Pret subscription redemptions worldwide, millions.

34.7M
2021
57.9M
2022
Source: Pret A Manger half-year results release, July 18, 2023. 57.9 / 34.7 = 1.67, our arithmetic. Read November 15, 2026.

Sweetgreen piloted Sweetpass in January 2022 at $10 for $3 off a meal every day for a month, launched a paid Sweetpass+ tier nationally in April 2023, reported enrollment up 25% in the second half of that year and added a $100 annual option, then in February 2025 told members they would be moved to a new SG Rewards program, without saying how many members it had. Burger King's coffee subscription, in Restaurant Dive's words, never gained footing and was discontinued, and the same article cites McKinsey research that 40% of subscribers cancel in less than three months.

The price, the item and the limits are hard to get right the first time, and each of these chains adjusted after launch. A chain that can see from its own data how a pilot group behaved, and what they said about the value, gets to make that adjustment before the national launch instead of after it.

Restaurant subscription vs loyalty program: which works better?

They do different jobs, and the chains above ended up running them together. A free loyalty program rewards spending after the fact; a subscription takes money up front and rewards frequency. Taco Bell sells its pass inside its rewards app, which is how the pass fed new members into the loyalty program. Sweetgreen built its paid tier into its rewards program and in 2025 told members they would move to a single new program. In Mintel's research, 55% of restaurant goers belong to a loyalty program and 48% want more restaurants to offer subscriptions, while Mintel also warns that a monthly fee of $3, $5 or $10 is an easy line for a household to cut.

A subscription suits an item guests already buy often, such as coffee or a daily lunch, where the fee can buy a habit. A loyalty program suits a broader base that visits less often. For the risks of changing a program once members are used to it, see who leaves and who stays after a loyalty program change.

How do you test a subscription before a chain-wide launch?

Run it the way Taco Bell did, in a limited market with a price that varies by location, and measure four things:

  1. Incremental visits. Compare members' visits with their own visits before joining and with similar non-members who visited as often before the launch, over the same weeks. The gap between that and the raw member-versus-everyone figure is the discount you gave to regulars. The same logic is set out in measuring the real lift from a discount.
  2. Add-on spend. Ticket size on redemption visits, against the same guests' tickets before.
  3. Renewal and after. The share who pay for a second month, and what lapsed members do in the month after the pass ends.
  4. What members and non-members say. App reviews, survey comments and messages that mention the pass, its limits, its value and cancelling, by location.

For choosing the pilot locations, see how to pick pilot locations before a rollout. A pilot measured this way also feeds a customer world model, so the decision on price and limits for the national launch starts from how your own pilot guests behaved; the wider method is in how to test a business decision before you make it.

How does Dimension Labs help a chain judge a paid program?

Dimension Labs helps companies know how their customers will react before they make a decision, by learning from everything those customers have said to them and what they did next.

A COO weighing a subscription would use all four parts of the platform. It is fully omni-channel, so a comment about the pass counts whether it came in an app review, a survey, an email or a chat. It integrates customer channels with operational data, joining those conversations to transactions, visits and renewals by location, so incremental visits among members can be measured against comparable guests with a range; that join and effects with confidence intervals are on Prove ($2,999 a month) and up. It enriches every interaction with Dimensions written for your business, such as "pass not worth it", "limit too low" or "cancelled after the first month", usable by marketing, finance and operations alike; custom Dimensions start on Discover ($999 a month). And its visual analytics layer turns the result into a deck, a dashboard, a PDF or executive report, or an interactive data story the leadership team can open by market.

The NBA uses Dimension Labs on Voice of Fan surveys that cover in-venue and digital products including NBA League Pass, and uses it to identify churn signals and upsell indicators directly from fan language; review cycles went from about 60 days to under 6 hours (NBA story). A paid restaurant program raises the same two questions, who would pay more and who is about to cancel, and the answers are in what members say.

For a single cafe, counting members and renewals in the point-of-sale or app is the simpler choice. Dimension Labs is built for a chain with many locations, feedback arriving through several channels, and a decision about price and limits to make before the program reaches every market.

FAQ

Do restaurant subscription programs work?

They raise visits among members: Taco Bell reported members three times more likely to visit per month. How much of that is new depends on how loyal the buyers already were, and none of the public results we found separates the two.

How much should a restaurant subscription cost?

Public examples: Taco Bell tested $5 to $10 for a taco a day for 30 days and launched at $10; Sweetpass+ cost $10 a month or $100 a year for $3 off a daily order; Club Pret charges £5 a month for 50% off up to five drinks a day. Test the price in a few markets before you set it.

Is a subscription better than a loyalty program?

It works best for items guests already buy often, and the chains above ran it inside their loyalty programs rather than instead of one.

What is the best way to tell whether a subscription would add visits for our chain?

For a multi-location chain, Dimension Labs: it labels every review, survey comment and chat about the program, joins them to transactions and visits by location on Prove, and measures members' incremental visits against comparable guests in the pilot markets, with a range. A single location can start with its member count, renewals and a read of what members say.

Bring one export of guest reviews or survey comments with your location list and start with one file to see what your guests already say about value and visiting more often. Every plan from Explore to Scale starts with a 14-day free trial.

Dimension Labs/Start with one file From $299 a month

Stop reporting. Start understanding.

Start with one file. Ask why a number moved. Plans from $299 a month, no demo and no contract on monthly plans.