Do Tripadvisor and Google Reviews Say the Same Thing About a Hotel?
Review platforms mostly agree on which places are better and disagree on how good each is. The published evidence, the reasons, and a labelled worked example for comparing your own hotels.
Partly. Studies that compare review platforms find they mostly agree on which places are better and disagree on how good each one is: Google ratings tend to run higher, and the written reviews on each site describe different parts of the stay. We found no large published study of Google and Tripadvisor for the same hotels, so the evidence below comes from attractions, restaurants and hotel comparisons with Booking.com, followed by a worked example on labelled sample data that shows how to check your own properties. For a hotel group that wants both platforms read the same way, next to surveys and guest messages, Dimension Labs fits best, because it enriches every review from every source with the same Dimensions for hotels and reports the results property by property.
Are Google ratings higher than Tripadvisor ratings?
Usually, in the research available. A 2024 study of Europe's 10 most visited museums and theme parks found that destinations "tend to have higher ratings on Google than on TripAdvisor". A comparison of Google Maps and Yelp covering 21,841 restaurants in seven US metro areas, found Google Maps ratings 0.7 stars higher than Yelp ratings on average, and higher for 93% of the restaurants.
Two findings from that restaurant study matter for hotel groups. The gap was larger for chains: 1.1 stars for chain restaurants against 0.6 for independents. And the platforms ranked restaurants only somewhat alike, with a correlation of 0.74 between the two average ratings. Whether branded hotels show the same chain effect between Google and Tripadvisor has not been published, as far as we found; it is a question your own data can answer.
Hotel studies that compare Tripadvisor with Booking.com point the same way on rankings. Across about 20,000 hotels matched in 447 cities, the two sites' rankings had a Spearman correlation of 0.87. For 182 hotels in Rimini, Tripadvisor averaged 4.20 against Booking.com's 4.11 on a five-point scale, was higher for 116 of the 182 hotels, and was more spread out (standard deviation 0.92 against 0.76).
Published research
Platforms tend to agree on which places are better, not on how good they are
Cross-platform rating comparisons we could find and read in full or in abstract. No large published study compares Google and Tripadvisor for the same hotels.
| Study | Sample | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Li and Hecht, 2020 Google Maps vs Yelp | 21,841 restaurants, 7 US metro areas | Google 0.7 stars higher on average; higher on Google for 93% of restaurants; chains 1.1 stars higher, independents 0.6 |
| Mellinas and Sicilia, 2024 Google vs Tripadvisor | Europe's 10 most visited museums and theme parks; 46,506 reviews | Destinations tend to rate higher on Google; Google gathers more reviews but shows at most 1,140 per destination |
| Figini, Vici and Viglia, 2020 Tripadvisor vs Booking.com | 182 hotels in Rimini, 68,186 reviews | Tripadvisor 4.20 vs Booking.com 4.11 on a 5-point scale; Tripadvisor higher at 116 of 182 hotels and more spread out |
| Martin-Fuentes, Mateu and Fernandez, 2018 Tripadvisor vs Booking.com | About 20,000 hotels matched in 447 cities | Rankings closely agree: Spearman correlation 0.87 |
What this means for a GM: a property that is 4.4 on Google and 4.1 on Tripadvisor is not necessarily slipping on one of them. Compare each platform with itself over time, and compare your hotels with each other on the same platform, before reading anything into the gap between platforms.
Why do Google and Tripadvisor reviews differ?
Mostly because of who writes and what each site asks them to do.
Google accepts a rating without a review. Google's help page says that to score a place you click the stars, and you "can also write a review". Guests who stop at the stars leave nothing to read, which is one reason written reviews read more negative than the rating; why written reviews skew below your star rating covers it.
Google gathers more reviews, and shows fewer of them. The attractions study found Google had greater potential to accumulate reviews but capped viewable and downloadable reviews at 1,140 per destination. If you collect Google reviews from the public page for a study, check that you have all of them before comparing counts.
Both sites filter heavily. Tripadvisor received 31.1 million reviews in 2024, stopped 2.7 million fraudulent ones and had its Trust and Safety team moderate 13.5% of all reviews. Google says it blocked or removed more than 240 million policy-violating reviews in 2024. Neither number is a rate you can compare, but both mean the reviews you see have already been screened.
Verification changes the shape. In the Rimini study, Booking.com accepted reviews only after a booking while Tripadvisor did not require proof of a reservation (the authors' description, data collected in 2016), and the unverified platform scored higher and varied more.
How do you compare Google and Tripadvisor reviews for your own hotels?
We did not publish a two-platform analysis of real hotels here; public review text is rarely licensed for that kind of reuse. The worked example below uses synthetic reviews for eight fictional hotels so every step can be shown. The numbers are made up; the method is the one to run on your own data.
Pull both sources with the same fields: property, date, star rating, text (empty when there is none) and platform. Keep stars-only Google ratings as rows; they count toward the rating even though they say nothing.
Compare levels within each platform. In the example, Google averages 4.17 across 8,320 reviews and Tripadvisor 4.04 across 2,920; the Google figure is higher at every hotel, by 0.04 to 0.34 stars. That gap says little about the hotels.
Compare ranks across platforms. The two best hotels hold their places on both sites, but the Convention Center hotel is fourth of eight on Google (4.17) and seventh on Tripadvisor (3.83), while Old Town Inn moves the other way, fifth to third. A hotel that ranks very differently on the two sites is the one to read first.
Worked example, synthetic data
Same eight hotels, two platforms: the top two hold, the rest reshuffle
Eight fictional hotels ranked by average Google rating and by average Tripadvisor rating.
Tag the written reviews from both platforms with the same Dimensions (room condition, cleanliness, staff, value, noise and so on) and compare shares of written reviews, not of all reviews. In the example, 37.9% of Google ratings have no text.
Expect Tripadvisor to name more. Its written reviews in the example name 2.18 topics each against 0.89 on Google, and complain about room condition in 20.2% of reviews against 5.9%. That does not mean rooms are worse for Tripadvisor guests. It means the detail lives there.
Worked example, synthetic data
Tripadvisor's written reviews name problems far more often
Share of written reviews that complain about each topic. Google written reviews name 0.89 topics on average; Tripadvisor reviews name 2.18.
GoogleTripadvisor
Measure what each problem does to the rating within each platform, then compare. If room condition costs about the same number of stars on both sites, the two platforms agree on what matters and you can pool them for the problem ranking. If they differ, report them separately.
The same reasoning applies to any second source: OTA reviews, post-stay surveys, guest emails. Our analysis of 9,446 public Google reviews of 45 Orlando hotels, in which the share of poor stays ran from 7.89% to 41.18% across hotels, shows how much properties differ even on one platform. The Orlando hotel review analysis shows the full read, and comparing guest reviews across hotels with different operators covers fair comparisons across a portfolio.
Which platform should a hotel GM watch?
Both, for different reasons. Google carries the rating shown in Google Search and Maps, and usually more reviews, so it is the better gauge of the rating itself. Tripadvisor, in the attractions study's words, "offers a more comprehensive and accessible source of information", so it is often where the specific problem is described. Read them together, tagged the same way, and keep the ratings separate. For groups with many properties, analyzing Google reviews across 50+ locations covers the Google side, and review response tools vs review analytics covers what to do after the reading.
What does it take to read both platforms in one place for every property?
Dimension Labs is an omni-channel analytics agent for customer data. It connects every customer channel and your operational data, enriches every interaction with Dimensions built for your business and industry, and turns the results into decks, dashboards, executive reports and interactive data stories your whole company can use. Plans start at $299 a month with no demo.
For a hotel group, that is four things. It is fully omni-channel: Google reviews come in from the Google Business Profile API with each star rating and owner reply, and Tripadvisor, OTA and survey exports come in as files, each row keeping its platform. It integrates with operational data, so ratings can sit next to property, brand tier and occupancy; the join to revenue data and effects with confidence intervals are on Prove at $2,999 a month. It enriches every review on every platform with the same Dimensions written for hotels, so a cleanliness complaint counts once whether it was written on Google or Tripadvisor (custom Dimensions start on Discover at $999 a month). And the agent builds each property's monthly report and the portfolio dashboard, downloadable as PDF or PowerPoint and shared by a link you can revoke.
Putting every channel in one layer pays for itself: Travelers, which joined its customer conversations into one layer with Dimension Labs, reports 600% ROI within 18 months and $3.13M in total savings. See guest experience analytics for hotels.
FAQ
Why is my hotel rated higher on Google than on Tripadvisor?
Google ratings run higher than other platforms in the published comparisons we found, and Google accepts star ratings with no written review. A gap between the two is normal; a change in the gap over time, or a hotel that ranks very differently on the two, is worth investigating.
Are Tripadvisor reviews more reliable than Google reviews?
Both screen reviews before and after posting, and both remove large numbers of fake ones. In the attractions study, Tripadvisor was the more comprehensive source of information and Google gathered more reviews. Use both, for different purposes.
What is the best way to analyze Google and Tripadvisor reviews together?
For a hotel group that wants both platforms, plus surveys and guest messages, tagged with the same hotel Dimensions and reported property by property, Dimension Labs. For one property and a few hundred reviews, a spreadsheet with a consistent list of topics works.
Should I combine Google and Tripadvisor into one rating?
No. Report each platform's rating separately, because their levels differ for reasons that have nothing to do with the hotel. Combine the written reviews after tagging them, to rank problems.
To compare the two platforms for your own properties, start with one file of Google and Tripadvisor reviews for a few hotels. Plans start at $299 a month with no demo.