How to Analyze SMG Survey Comments Alongside Google and Yelp Reviews
Survey comments and online reviews come from different guests and rank problems differently. Here is how to read them side by side, location by location.
To analyze SMG survey comments together with Google and Yelp reviews, put both in one table keyed by location and date, label every comment and every review with the same list of themes, and compare the two sources location by location instead of pooling them, because the guests who answer a post-visit survey and the guests who write a review are different groups. If your reviews already come into SMG, its Comment Explorer puts survey, review, digital and contact center comments in one view, and that is the place to start. For a restaurant group that wants those comments read with Dimensions built for its own menu and service model, joined to POS, labor and delivery data, and turned into a report for every location, Dimension Labs adds that layer next to SMG.
What does SMG already do with survey comments and reviews?
SMG's platform already covers a lot of this question. SMG describes Comment Explorer as bringing comments from surveys and reviews into one view with AI summaries, Knowledge Agent as a way to ask the feedback questions in plain language, and Location Home as each manager's view of what hurts satisfaction most at their location. Both of SMG's software packages, Standard and Pro UXM, list ratings and reviews and data integration and exporting options.
From smg.com, read 2026-11-17
SMG already brings survey comments and online reviews into one view
The parts of SMG's platform that handle comments and reviews, in SMG's own words, and what each is for.
| SMG tool | What SMG says it does | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Comment Explorer | Brings comments from surveys, reviews, digital and contact center into one view; summarizes thousands of comments with AI; flags critical comments | Reading survey comments and reviews side by side inside SMG |
| Knowledge Agent | Ask questions in plain language; compare products, locations and time periods | Quick questions across the feedback in SMG |
| Location Home | Shows the two areas that hurt satisfaction most, open cases, and the location against its region and company goals | Each manager's own view |
| Loop | Brings online reviews and survey cases into one workflow, with AI-drafted replies | Replying and closing the loop |
| Packages | Standard and Pro UXM; both include ratings and reviews and data integration and exporting options | Getting the data out to join elsewhere |
So the question is less "can we see them together" than "what do we do with them together". The steps below work inside SMG or outside it. They matter most when the comments need to meet data that lives elsewhere: sales by daypart, staffing, delivery-app ratings, or support tickets from the app.
Where do the Google and Yelp reviews come from?
For Google, the Business Profile API lets you list all reviews for a location you manage, get reviews from several locations at once, and reply. Our Google reviews integration uses that API. For Yelp, the public reviews endpoint returns up to three review excerpts for a business, so check with Yelp, or with the review vendor you already use, how you can get full review text under Yelp's terms. On the survey side, take the SMG export with the comment, the overall satisfaction score, the location number, the visit date and the order channel.
How do you put survey comments and reviews in one table?
Use one layout. One row per comment or review: source (survey, Google, Yelp), location number, visit or review date, score, order channel when you have it, and the text. Keep the score on its own scale; a satisfaction score and a star rating are not the same measure.
Map every review to a location number. Survey rows carry your store number; reviews carry a Google place or a Yelp business. Build the map once and check it by hand for locations that moved, closed or share a parking lot.
Label both sources with one theme list. Write the themes in your guests' words (wait time, order accuracy, food temperature, staff attitude, cleanliness, price, app orders) and ask the same questions of every row, with "none of these" allowed. Our posts on survey text analysis and building a codeframe for open-ended responses cover the list.
Compare inside each source first. Rank themes in survey comments, then in reviews, then look at the gap. Pooled counts are dominated by whichever source has more rows, often the survey.
Compare each location with its own baseline. A location's share for a theme against the chain's share in the same source, with enough comments behind it to mean something; comparing NPS across locations fairly covers the sample-size side.
Why don't survey comments and reviews rank problems the same way?
Because they come from different guests at different moments. A post-visit survey invites guests to answer questions about a visit; a review is written by a guest who chose to post one. To show what that looks like, we built a sample for a fictional 40-location chain: 3,026 low-score survey comments and 616 one- and two-star Google and Yelp reviews over 12 weeks, all labelled with the same seven themes. The numbers are invented; the gap is the kind to look for.
In this synthetic sample, wait time led the survey comments at 33.3% and came fourth in reviews at 19.5%. Staff attitude went the other way: 9.8% of survey comments and 30.8% of low reviews, first in reviews. Order accuracy was second in both (28.8% and 24.4%), which makes it the theme with the strongest case for action: two groups of guests, asked in two ways, name it.
Worked example, synthetic sample data
Surveys rank wait time first; one- and two-star reviews rank staff attitude first; order accuracy is second in both
Seven themes, labelled the same way in 3,026 low-score survey comments and 616 one- and two-star Google and Yelp reviews from a fictional 40-location chain, ranked by the share that names each.
The location view is where the two sources disagree most. In the sample, each source picked its own eight worst locations for order accuracy, and they shared three. The median location had 74 low-score survey comments and 15 low reviews in the period, so a location's review share can swing on a few posts.
Worked example, synthetic sample data
Picked by each source on its own, the eight worst locations for order accuracy overlap on three
Locations in the top 8 of 40 for the share of negative feedback naming order accuracy, by source.
A practical rule follows. Rank locations on the source with more rows behind each location, which in this sample is the survey by about five to one. Use reviews to catch themes the survey under-reports, such as staff attitude and cleanliness in this sample, and treat a location that shows up in both as the first call to make. Our post on analyzing Google reviews across 50 or more locations covers the review side in more depth, and combining reviews with POS sales by location covers the join to sales.
Why would a restaurant group that runs SMG add Dimension Labs?
Dimension Labs is an omni-channel analytics agent for customer data. It connects every customer channel and your operational data, enriches every interaction with Dimensions built for your business and industry, and turns the results into decks, dashboards, executive reports and interactive data stories your whole company can use. Plans start at $299 a month with no demo.
For a chain on SMG, the SMG export is one source next to Google and Yelp reviews, delivery-app ratings, app store reviews, support tickets and catering emails, all read with one set of Dimensions so a wrong-order complaint counts the same way wherever it came from. The integration side joins those rows to POS sales, labor schedules and location attributes; the join to revenue data with effects and confidence intervals is on Prove at $2,999 a month. Enrichment uses Dimensions written in plain English for your menu, order channels and service model (custom Dimensions start on Discover at $999 a month). The visual analytics layer builds the operations deck, a page per region and a dashboard for the brand team, downloadable as PDF or PowerPoint, shared by a link you can revoke, and rerun on a schedule into the Final Reports folder. SMG stays where location managers work day to day; Dimension Labs is where the cross-source analysis and the joins to operations happen.
The NBA uses Dimension Labs on its Voice of Fan surveys and reports insight review cycles cut from about 60 days to under 6 hours, with more than 100,000 open-ended responses analyzed within hours. See the NBA story, and restaurant guest feedback analytics for the restaurant setup.
When SMG on its own is the better choice: if your reviews already flow into SMG and the questions are about survey and review themes by location, Comment Explorer, Knowledge Agent and Location Home answer them where your managers already work. Joining those comments to sales, staffing and every other channel, with themes built for your business, is the job Dimension Labs is built for.
FAQ
Can SMG show survey comments and online reviews together?
Yes. SMG says Comment Explorer brings comments from surveys, reviews, digital and contact center into one view, and Loop brings online reviews and survey cases into one workflow.
Should survey comments and reviews be pooled into one score?
No. Keep the source as a field and compare within each source first. Pooled counts follow whichever source has more rows, and the two groups of guests differ. Our post on why written reviews skew below the star rating covers one reason.
How many reviews does a location need before you compare it?
Enough that a few posts do not move its share. In the sample above, the median location had 15 low reviews in 12 weeks against 74 low-score survey comments, so survey comments carried the location ranking.
What is the best way to analyze SMG comments with reviews and operational data?
For a multi-location brand that wants SMG survey comments, Google and Yelp reviews and its other channels labelled with one set of Dimensions, joined to POS and labor data and reported per location, Dimension Labs. For side-by-side reading inside the survey platform, SMG's Comment Explorer.
To see your SMG export and your reviews read with one set of themes, start with one file. Every plan from Explore to Scale starts with a 14-day free trial.