Skip to content
Product
PlatformPricingDimensionsIntegrationsSecurityCompare
Solutions · by use case
Customer, guest and fan experienceProduct feedback and prioritizationRevenue, churn and retentionAgenciesContact center performanceAI agent and chatbot analyticsMulti-location performanceReviews and competitive benchmarking
Solutions · by industry
Hotels and hospitalityRestaurants and food serviceFitness and leisureRetail and e-commerceSports and live entertainmentInsuranceBanking and financial servicesSoftware and SaaSAutomotiveConsumer products and CPGContact centers and BPOsPublic sector and nonprofitReal estateGaming and betting
Learn
Artifacts GalleryCustomer storiesResearchBlogThought leadershipLessons Log in Start now
Blog

Raising the Free-Shipping Minimum: How Many Orders Do You Lose?

Only the orders between the old and new minimum are at risk. What Target's and Amazon's dated changes and three field studies show, with a worked break-even on synthetic data.

Raising a free-shipping minimum puts only the orders between the old minimum and the new one at risk, and the research says the shoppers in that band respond to the charge. In a 2021 University of Groningen working paper, when a large European online retailer replaced category shipping fees with a single fee waived above EUR 20, daily orders rose 43.6% in the categories where the fee fell, and Target's own explanation when it raised its minimum from $25 to $35 in 2017 was that only a small share of its orders fell below $35. For an online or omnichannel retailer that wants to know what its own band of customers will do (top up, pay the fee or go elsewhere), the clearest answer comes from its own record, and that is the job Dimension Labs does: it labels every review, chat, ticket and survey comment that mentions shipping and sets them beside the orders those customers placed before and after the change.

Below: the dated threshold changes at Target and Amazon, what three field studies measured, a worked break-even on a labelled synthetic sample, and how to measure the change on your own orders. Fees added at the register, rather than at checkout online, are covered in how customers react to service fees and surcharges.

What happens if we raise our free shipping minimum?

Three groups of orders see three different things. Orders already above the new minimum see nothing. Orders below the old minimum already paid the fee and still do. Only the band in between changes: those customers now choose between adding items, paying for shipping, waiting to combine orders or buying somewhere else. So the first number to know is the size of that band, and it is the number Target used both times it moved its minimum. In 2015, when it cut the minimum from $50 to $25, about two-thirds of its orders already qualified, TechCrunch reported. In 2017, raising it to $35, it said only a small percentage of purchases were under $35 and that REDcard holders would keep free shipping with no minimum.

The largest U.S. online retailer has moved its minimum in both directions. Amazon raised its non-Prime minimum from $25 to $35 in 2013 and to $49 in February 2016, then cut it back to $35 in February 2017 and to $25 that May, after Walmart offered free two-day shipping at $35. In August 2023 it tested $35 again for some customers depending on where they lived, with Seattle at $25 and nearby Bellevue at $35. That last change is the most useful design for anyone planning their own: a higher minimum in some places and the old one in others gives you a comparison group.

Dated decisions

Target and Amazon moved their minimums seven times in ten years, in both directions

Free-shipping minimums for shoppers without a membership, as reported at the time of each change.

DateRetailerChangeWhat was said
Oct 2013Amazon$25 to $35Raised for non-Prime customers
Feb 23, 2015Target$50 to $25About two-thirds of orders already qualified
Feb 22, 2016Amazon$35 to $49Non-Prime orders only
Feb 2017Amazon$49 to $35After Walmart's free two-day offer at $35
May 2017Amazon$35 to $25Not publicized, spotted by a deals site
May 7, 2017Target$25 to $35No press release; 'a small percentage' of orders under $35; REDcard holders exempt
Aug 2023Amazon$25 to $35A test in some locations, by where the customer lives
Sources: CS Monitor, 2015; TechCrunch, 2015; Retail Dive, 2016; TechCrunch, 2017; Fortune, 2017; NBC News, 2023. Target's 2017 change was made on the Sunday before Fortune's May 10 report. All read November 19, 2026.

What customers said about these changes is a weaker signal than what they did. After Amazon's 2016 increase, 96% of non-Prime respondents to a Dealnews survey of 1,360 people said it would change how they shop there, and 52% said they were annoyed and planned to avoid shopping there on principle. Amazon reversed the increase within a year, but the public record does not say whether customers or competitors drove that. Stated intentions tend to overshoot behavior, as we set out in do customers do what they say; the band's orders before and after are the measure that counts.

Does a free shipping threshold increase order value?

It increases sales and orders more reliably than it increases the size of each order. Lewis, Singh and Fay studied an online retailer that had tried many shipping-fee schedules and found consumers very sensitive to shipping charges: free shipping and free shipping above a threshold were very effective at generating sales, but at that retailer the lost shipping revenue and the segments that did not respond made those promotions unprofitable.

The largest study we found is that Groningen working paper (a SOM research report), with 26.21 million orders from 3.81 million customers of a European online retailer that in November 2017 replaced category fees of up to EUR 5.95 with a EUR 2.95 fee and free shipping from EUR 20. Daily orders and sales rose by about 44% and 45% where fees fell, the authors found no significant change in average order value, and the model-free averages in the chart show baskets 10.7% smaller as more small orders came in.

Working paper, read at the source

A free-shipping threshold brought more orders, slightly smaller baskets and slightly more returns

A European online retailer before and after it replaced category shipping fees with a EUR 2.95 fee and free shipping from EUR 20, November 2017. Change in the daily average, model-free.

Orders per day17,313 to 24,786
+43.2%
Sales per dayEUR 2.57m to 3.27m
+27.2%
Average order valueEUR 148.12 to 132.22
-10.7%
Source: Hirche, Gijsenberg and Bijmolt, University of Groningen working paper, 2021, 26.21 million orders, July 2017 to June 2019. Share of products returned went from 43% to 45%. Percentage changes computed by us from the reported averages. The authors' models put the order increase at 43.6% where fees fell and find no significant change in order value.

The top-ups are real but small. Items added last that lifted a basket over the threshold were 2.49% of products, with a median price of EUR 17.95, just under the EUR 20 line, and they were returned less often than other items. The authors' simulation found that a retailer with the average online gross margin of 42.5% always profits from the threshold policy, and only a retailer with a margin of 37.5% or less and return handling costs of EUR 12 an item would do better with flat fees. Their review also notes the direction that matters for this page: in Lepthien and Clement's 2019 study, a higher threshold led to fewer orders.

Will customers abandon carts if we charge for shipping?

Some will, and shipping costs are the reason shoppers name most often. Among U.S. online shoppers who abandoned a cart for a reason other than just browsing, 40% named extra costs such as shipping, tax and fees in Baymard Institute's survey, and 12% said they could not see the total cost up front. That is a stated reason, so treat it as an upper bound on the risk.

Free shipping also changes what people buy and send back. In Shehu, Papies and Neslin's study, free shipping promotions led customers to spend more on products that are harder to judge online, which raised the overall return rate, a result the authors confirmed in a field experiment; in their simulation for that retailer, higher returns and lost shipping revenue made the promotions unprofitable even though net sales rose. Returns belong in the calculation from the start, and if you are changing who pays for them at the same time, read what a return policy change does to customers first.

How do you work out whether a higher minimum pays?

Price each of the four outcomes for an order in the band, then ask how many band customers you can lose before the change costs margin. To show the arithmetic, we built a synthetic sample: a fictional online store with 100,000 orders a month moves its minimum from $35 to $50, and 18% of its orders sit between the two.

Synthetic sample, labelled

Raising the minimum paid in this sample because most customers in the band stayed

A fictional store moves its minimum from $35 to $50. Monthly gross margin from the 18,000 orders between the two, after the $7 it pays to ship each order, in thousands of dollars.

$176.4K
Band margin today
+$50.4K
Customers who top up
+$27.0K
Customers who pay the fee
-$44.1K
Customers who leave
$209.7K
Band margin after
Synthetic sample data for a fictional online store, not a real company: 18% of 100,000 monthly orders sit between $35 and $50, 40% gross margin, $7 to ship an order, a $5.99 fee, $14 average top-up; half the band tops up, a quarter pays, a quarter leaves. Replace every input with your own.

In the synthetic sample, each band order earns $9.80 today after the store pays $7 to ship it. A customer who tops up by $14 adds $5.60; one who pays the $5.99 fee adds $5.99; one who leaves takes the $9.80 with them. With half the band topping up, a quarter paying and a quarter leaving, the band's monthly margin rises from $176.4K to $209.7K. The store could lose up to 36.9% of band customers before this month's margin fell, and each customer it loses would have to place only about 0.75 more orders of the same size in later months to cancel the gain. That last number is why the decision rests on who the band customers are: occasional buyers of small items, or regulars who buy often and below the line.

Three inputs move the answer most. The band share, which your order data gives you exactly. The split between top-up, pay and leave, which a test in some regions or for some customers gives you. And the value of the customers who leave, which only the history of those customers can tell you; comparing what churned and retained customers said shows how to find the ones at risk before they go.

How do you measure what the change did after it ships?

  1. Keep a comparison group. Raise the minimum for some regions, some customer groups or some weeks first, the way Amazon's 2023 test varied by location. Members or cardholders who keep free shipping, as Target's REDcard holders did, are a second comparison, though they shop differently.
  2. Follow the band, not the average. Count orders between the old and new minimums, top-ups, fee payments and the customers who stop ordering, against the comparison group over the same weeks. The average order value alone mixes all three.
  3. Read what customers said about shipping. Label every review, chat, support ticket and survey answer that names the minimum, the fee or delivery speed, by region and week, and separate complaints about the charge from complaints about not seeing it until checkout.
  4. Watch returns and repeat orders for two to three months. Returns of top-up items and the next order from band customers decide whether the first month's margin holds.

For choosing which regions or stores go first, see how to pick pilot locations before a rollout. The general method is in how to test a business decision on your customers before you make it, and each change measured this way adds to a customer world model, so the next shipping decision starts from how your own customers reacted to the last one.

What would Dimension Labs show before you move the minimum?

Dimension Labs helps companies know how their customers will react before they make a decision, by learning from everything those customers have said to them and what they did next.

For a head of e-commerce or a CFO weighing a new minimum, each part of the platform answers a piece of it. It is fully omni-channel, so a complaint about the shipping fee counts the same whether it came in a product review, a chat, a support ticket or a post-purchase survey. It integrates customer channels with operational data, joining those conversations to orders, baskets, returns and repeat purchases by region and customer, so the effect of a past threshold change, or of a test in some regions, can be measured with a range; that join and effects with confidence intervals are on Prove ($2,999 a month) and up. It enriches every interaction with Dimensions written for your business, such as "fee appeared at checkout", "added an item to reach free shipping" or "shipping slower than promised", that finance, e-commerce and support can all use; custom Dimensions start on Discover ($999 a month). And its visual analytics layer turns the result into a deck, a dashboard, a PDF or executive report, or an interactive data story for the team that sets the policy.

Intuit QuickBooks runs Dimension Labs on more than one million chatbot sessions a month across 50+ bots, enriching each one with intent, fallback drivers, journey stage and escalation triggers, and its story reports a 35.3% reduction in the fallback intent rate and a 57% reduction in human escalations (Intuit story). Questions about delivery charges and order minimums come in through the same kind of chat and support traffic, and at a retailer they arrive by the thousand in the weeks after a minimum moves.

When something simpler is the better choice: if you sell through one storefront and only need the share of orders in the band, your e-commerce platform's order report gives it, and a split test from your checkout tool can measure conversion. Dimension Labs earns its place when customers write to you through several channels, when the decision touches returns and repeat orders, and when you want to know which customers a higher minimum would cost before it reaches all of them.

FAQ

What is a good free shipping threshold?

One set just above the order size most of your customers already reach, so the band you move is small and the top-up is easy. Target raised its minimum to $35 in 2017 because only a small share of its orders were below it; in the Groningen working paper, items added to reach a EUR 20 threshold had a median price of EUR 17.95.

Does raising the free shipping minimum lose customers?

It can lose orders in the band between the old and new minimums, and a 2019 study, as summarized in the Groningen working paper, found a higher threshold led to fewer orders. Whether it loses money depends on how many in the band top up or pay instead, and what the ones who leave were worth.

Is free shipping above a threshold better than a flat shipping fee?

In the largest study we found, a 2021 working paper, the threshold policy brought more orders and sales, slightly more returns, and higher profit for any retailer with an average or better gross margin. Two other studies found free shipping offers unprofitable for their retailers once lost fees and returns were counted, so check it on your own margins.

What is the best way to measure a shipping minimum change?

For a retailer with orders and customer comments across several channels, Dimension Labs: it labels every review, chat and ticket about shipping, joins them to orders and returns on Prove, and measures the change against regions or customers that kept the old minimum, with a range. A single storefront can start with its platform's order report and a checkout split test.

Export a few months of orders and customer comments that mention shipping, and start with one file to see how your customers took your last shipping change. Every plan from Explore to Scale starts with a 14-day free trial.

Dimension Labs/Start with one file From $299 a month

Stop reporting. Start understanding.

Start with one file. Ask why a number moved. Plans from $299 a month, no demo and no contract on monthly plans.